Book Review: THE HUSBAND'S SECRET by Liane Moriarty

Title: The Husband's Secret
Author: Liane Moriarty
Publisher: Pan MacMillan Australia
Read: March 31 - April 01, 2013



Synopsis (Goodreads):

The Husband's Secret is a funny, heartbreaking novel of marriage, grief, love and secrets. When her husband announces he's in love with her best friend, painfully shy Tess picks up her young son and returns to her mother's house. There she begins an unexpected affair with an old flame. Rachel is a woman in her sixties consumed by grief and anger at the loss of her daughter twenty years earlier. When her son announces he is taking her beloved grandson overseas, Rachel begins a descent into deeper bitterness and pain. Cecilia is the quintessential "I don't know how she does it" woman. A devoted mother to three daughters, she runs her household like clockwork, is President of the P&C, owns an extremely successful Tupperware business and is happy in her fifteen-year marriage. Until she discovers a letter in their attic labelled: "To my wife Cecilia, to be opened in the event of my death"... Her husband's secret is a bombshell beyond all imagining with repercussions across the lives of all three women.


My thoughts:

I loved all of Liane Moriarty’s previous books, and was therefore very excited to find out that her latest novel was available for download from Amazon. It quickly solved my dilemma of the dreadfully difficult decision of which book on my looooooong tbr list to read next (maybe if I was as organised as Cecilia I would have a better system than the eeny-meeny-miny-mo method I usually employ, coupled with much nail-biting and doubt over my final decision). And The Husband’s Secret did not disappoint – Moriarty’s gift of making her characters almost real flesh-and-blood people, coupled with the offer of an unexpected roster day off from work, made for an intense read-a-thon which saw me finishing this book in a few hours of sheer reading bliss.

From the premise of the novel to the very last detail of its execution The Husband’s Secret had me totally in its grip and still causes some soul searching even now after the last page has been turned. What would you do if you found a letter written to you by your husband years ago, marked “to be opened in the event of my death”? Cecilia of course wants to do the right thing – she is the queen of proper decision-making (no eeny-meeny-miny-mo for her), and decides to ask her husband John-Paul about it first. His reaction is so baffling that for once Cecilia does give in to temptation – and opens the letter. Its contents are so startling, so mind-blowing that her life, and that of their three daughters, can never be the same again. No matter of organising, smoothing-over or patching-up will ever fix this mess, and for the first time in her life Cecilia finds herself totally out of her depth.

Told in the third-person narrative, the book’s chapters are written from the perspective of three different people, who are seemingly unconnected in the beginning of the novel.

Tess, part owner and operator of a small advertising agency in Melbourne and mother of a six-year old son, has little idea of how her life is about to change when her husband and her cousin take her aside in the middle of her favourite TV show to confess that they have fallen in love. Feeling betrayed and heartbroken she takes her son and flees to Sydney under the guise of helping her mother cope after breaking her ankle. It is there that she runs into an ex-boyfriend she last saw when she was nineteen, and who is still very attracted to her.

Rachel, who after twenty-eight years is still mourning the tragic death of her teenage daughter Janie, is having to face losing her beloved grandson when her son and daughter-in-law announce their planned move to New York. This decision, coupled with the imminent anniversary of Janie’s death, brings back renewed feelings of loss and grief for Rachel, who contemplates a lonely life on her own in Sydney.

Through Cecilia and the startling revelation in John-Paul’s letter these three women’s lives become intertwined in ways none of them could have imagined.

I loved the premise of the book, the question of “what if” which seems to have become a popular theme in modern literature. Perhaps because every one of us at some stage in our lives will ask this question: “What if I had acted differently? How would my life have changed?” Moriarty answers this existential question perfectly in her epilogue, bringing together all the threads of the story and presenting a very satisfying finale – but enough said, there will be no spoilers from me.

Inspired by real-life death-bed confessions, Moriarty’s novel raises a lot of moral and ethical questions of what constitutes “the right thing”. I may have been quite black-and-white in my answer prior to reading this novel, but vacillated constantly between different answers as several angles were explored. I may be a terrible decision maker, but in the face of such controversy, even the super organised Cecilia never stood a chance (of course she had a lot more to lose as well). And just when you may have thought that “the right thing” is pretty clear, the author challenges it with some startling revelations at the very end of the book. Amazing.

What I also love about Moriarty’s writing is the authenticity of her characters. All three main protagonists are the women-next-door, the mothers you see at the school gates, the members of your bookclub or the people standing in front of you in the supermarket queue. It brings the events unfolding even closer to home, thinking that this could happen to anyone, at any time. I had such vivid pictures in my mind of all characters involved that their personalities, their families and their homes seemed like I had seen them in real life. Perhaps the only thing I missed in this novel was the tongue-in-cheek humour found in “What Alice Forgot”, which still makes it my favourite Moriarty book to-date.

Apart from secrets kept and secrets exposed, marriage and motherhood feature as strongly in The Husband’s Secret as in previous novels. As a mother, decisions no longer involve just a single person, but have grave outcomes on the people you love most.

“You’re a mother. You’d do anything for your children, just like I’d do anything for mine. “

Would I, or wouldn’t I? If it involved my own children, yes, I probably would. Regardless of moral and ethical dilemmas, like a lioness protecting her cub I wouldn’t hesitate to defend my young. And this is where it becomes tricky of course. Although in Virginia's shoes I don't think I could just turn a blind eye, I would have to confront my child and find out the truth, no matter how painful that may be.

Enough said. I loved this book. I fully recommend it. Go and buy it and see for yourself. If you enjoyed Moriarty’s previous novels, you will not be disappointed.

 I read this book as part of my 2013 Australian Women Writers Challenge; as well as my 2013 Monthly Keyword Challenge ("secret").

 

Book Review: SILVER ORPHAN by Martine Lacombe

Title: Silver Orphan
Author: Martine Lacombe
Publisher: Five Leaf Clover
Read: March 28-29, 2013


Synopsis (Goodreads):

An endearing tale of unlikely friendship and compassion between two diametrically opposed individuals - a vibrant young woman and an elderly frail man - Silver Orphan illustrates that giving of yourself reaps untold benefits.

The subject matter covered in Silver Orphan is disturbing from a collective point of view. How we treat our elders, how we discard them - both in life and death - mirrors how we fare as a society. The old will soon outnumber the young - a chilling prospect treated with compassion in Silver Orphan. Interwoven in the stark reality of our superficial ethos is a story of love, redemption, and compassion. Silver Orphan should be included in ethics class curricula nationwide. A chance encounter; an unusual request; two lives inexorably transformed.

When self-absorbed Brooke Blake uncharacteristically sheds her narcissistic armor, she discovers that the hand we lend may pave the way to our own redemption. Silver Orphan is a perplexing hall of mirrors where every image reflects agonizing - though liberating - secrets.


My thoughts: 

When Brooke Blake, a young pharmaceutical sales rep with a general loathing for humanity at large, sees an elderly man stranded on the side of the road trying to hitch a ride, it touches some deep forgotten thread of compassion and humanity inside her and compels her to give the stranger a lift. Out of the chance encounter develops an unlikely friendship. For the following eight months, Brooke regularly visits 86-year-old Frank Moretti to take him to the supermarket and help him with his shopping. In return, Frank teaches her about the simple pleasures in life, such as Twinkies and the famous Philly Cheesesteak. Brooke, who is as hard on herself as she is on other people and affords herself few pleasures, is slowly transformed by Frank’s friendship, discovering the joys of really caring for someone other than herself.

One day Brooke receives a phone call from the hospital – Frank has collapsed in the street and has passed away. There is no information about any next of kin, with Brooke’s phone number the only contact details Frank had on his person. Determined to give Frank the send-off he deserves, Brooke sets out to track down some information about Frank’s past in the hope of finding family members. Her investigations – albeit against her better judgment - will lead her on a road to discovery about her friend’s life she had never expected…

I received a Galley copy of Silver Orphan directly from the author in exchange for an honest review. I admit that the title of “a social novel” initially conjured visions of something dry and lecturing, which to my pleasant surprise this novel was not. Despite Brooke being painted in a very unfavourable light in the opening chapters, I did enjoy her somewhat acerbic humour, which elicited many chuckles. At times this humour was self-deprecating, but quite often it provided comical musings about some of the frustrating or perplexing moments in life most of us can relate to.

“I nod in acceptance of the diversion and sadly note that I most certainly committed this useless trivia to memory, leaving less room for useful knowledge. Such are the vagaries of the mind.”

Or:

“If I were on a television show, the place would fall silent and the toothless locals would all turn toward me, threatening me with pickaxes and slinging catfish in my direction. This being real life, nobody gives me the time of day.”

The Brooke who is quoted as saying: “ I really don’t like people. I tolerate a few other human beings, but as a whole, I find the whole human race to be rather disgusting”, turns into a completely different person when she is around Frank, although she would never admit to any altruistic motives. The slowly developing friendship between these two very different people is heartwarming and inspires hope.

And of course I loved Frank – the intrepid octogenarian whose past is gradually being revealed in alternating chapters written in first person narrative from a younger Frank’s perspective. Interspersed with many interesting facts about Philadelphia during the Great Depression and the fate of Italian immigrants during WW2, Frank’s life story lends another very humane aspect to the novel. As a health professional I often witness the careless dismissal of our elderly, without giving credit to the rich lives they have led. I applaud Martine Lacombe to highlight this scourge of our time and society with this heartwarming story of friendship and redemption.

My only criticism would be the way young Brooke initially reacts to Frank’s death, which seems out of character even in her most obnoxious moments. A girl who has taken the time to ferry her elderly friend around town on a regular basis for eight months, and seems generally concerned about his welfare, would certainly have felt some sadness over his passing – I get that the author wanted to paint Brooke in an unfavourable light to highlight her growth as a person throughout the novel – however, at that point in the story she had already been touched and transformed to some degree by the relationship.

All in all I derived a lot of pleasure from reading this novel and it validated a lot of encounters I personally had with elderly people, both in my professional and in my private life. It is a shame that our elders aren’t more respected in our society, as we have so much to learn from them. Silver Orphan is about respect, friendship and growth. I closed the book with a feeling of hope for a better world.

I applaud the author for tackling this difficult subject and believe she has done it justice and presented it in a format which provided both entertainment value as well as food for thought. I look forward to reading more from this promising young author in the future.

Book Review: BÖSER WOLF by Nele Neuhaus

Title: Böser Wolf
Author: Nele Neuhaus
Publisher: Ullstein
Read: March 24-28, 2013


Synopsis (Goodreads):

An einem heißen Tag im Juli wird die Leiche einer 16-Jährigen aus dem Main bei Eddersheim geborgen. Sie wurde misshandelt und ermordet, und niemand vermisst sie. Auch nach Wochen hat das K 11 keinen Hinweis auf ihre Identität. Die Spuren führen zu einem Kinderdorf im Taunus und zu einer Fernsehmoderatorin, die bei ihren Recherchen den falschen Leuten zu nahe gekommen ist. Pia Kirchhoff und Oliver von Bodenstein graben tiefer und stoßen inmitten gepflegter Bürgerlichkeit auf einen Abgrund an Bösartigkeit und Brutalität. Und dann wird der Fall persönlich.


My thoughts:

In her latest novel “Böser Wolf”, Nele Neuhaus goes one step further than in her five previous novels and lets her main characters investigate a crime which transcends local boundaries and uncovers a large conspiracy so evil that it will sicken and disturb most readers when thinking about these crimes happening to real people, in real life.

Several threads start in the first part of the book:

Pia Kirchhoff has settled into a comfortable life with her new partner Christoph, trying to get used to looking after a small child when his granddaughter Lilly comes for an extended visit from Australia. With Oliver von Bodenstein away on a trip, she is the first person on call when the mutilated body of a teenage girl is found floating in the Main. Despite extensive investigations into the identity of the girl, the team are unable to make real progress in the case, as nobody even seems to be missing the teenager. An autopsy reveals a horrific history of old injuries pointing to years of unspeakable abuse and captivity.

In the meantime Hanna Herrmann, a famous TV talkshow host, is about to contact a person who could potentially provide her with the biggest story of her career. After recent complaints about her and her show, which centres around heartbreak and personal disaster, often at the expense of the victims themselves, Hanna really needs this break to keep her show on air. But Hanna may have underestimated the lengths other people may go to to keep her from finding out the truth – brutally attacked, raped and left for dead she barely escapes with her life with no memory of how she got into this situation.

Emma, eight months pregnant with her second child, is worried about her five year old daughter, whose violent outbursts and strange behaviour seem too extreme to be the normal temper tantrums and mood swings of a child her age. On top of that, her husband has been acting cold and remote and Emma is sure that he is having an affair. At a school reunion Emma bumps into her old friend Pia Kirchhoff, and the two women reconnect again after many years.

In Neuhaus’ typical style, all these separate threads ultimately connect and culminate in a terrifying finale involving all characters, this time becoming very close and personal to Pia Kirchhoff’s own life.

Again I was totally captivated by the plot and found it hard to put the book down until all was revealed. Personally, I love the way Neuhaus introduces many separate storylines and characters, which make reading the novel an exciting journey and introduce many different interesting elements and angles. However, by centring the novel around a topic which elicits very strong emotions in most people, the violent and sexual crimes against children, I feel that Neuhaus paid the price of making the story a bit too black and white. In previous novels there were always several sides to the contemporary topic explored, with the varying emotional responses of supporting characters lending the story depth and credibility. A difficult topic such as explored in Böser Wolf creates many “no-go” zones, often at the expense of character development. I found that this led to several unanswered questions as to the motives and means of the main perpetrators in the novel, as well as a conspiracy almost too large to be believable for the setting.

However, Neuhaus’ passion about exposing the subject to the wider public is evident, and she certainly manages to elicit strong emotions through uncovering the horrible-beyond-words aspects of the crimes. I shudder to think of the emotional toll researching such a topic must take, and take my hat off to the author for being brave enough to tackle such a horrific task. Living quite a sheltered life in our quiet corner of the world here, I was sickened to think about organised crime against children – an unspeakable horror. In that regard Neuhaus’ latest thriller serves two purposes: the entertainment value of an intelligent, well-written murder-mystery combined with raising awareness of horrific crimes committed in our own environment. Since awareness is the first step to change, and packaging it in an approachable format is a great way to get the message out, I hope that the awareness Neuhaus raises with her novel will indeed work towards making a difference.

I thoroughly enjoyed reading this novel and found it hard to put down. Kirchhoff and von Bodenstein have become so familiar over the course of the series that I am eager to find out what the future holds for them, and look forward to Neuhaus’ next book in the series!

Audiobook Review: THE GIRL YOU LEFT BEHIND by Jojo Moyes

Title: The Girl You Left Behind
Author: Jojo Moyes
Narrators: Clare Corbett & Penny Rawlins

Publisher (audiobook version): Clipper Audiobooks

Read: March 08 - 27, 2013


Synopsis (Goodreads):

In 1916 French artist Edouard Lefevre leaves his wife Sophie to fight at the Front. When her town falls into German hands, his portrait of Sophie stirs the heart of the local Kommandant and causes her to risk everything - her family, reputation and life - in the hope of seeing her true love one last time.

Nearly a century later and Sophie's portrait is given to Liv by her young husband shortly before his sudden death. Its beauty speaks of their short life together, but when the painting's dark and passion-torn history is revealed, Liv discovers that the first spark of love she has felt since she lost him is threatened...

In The Girl You Left Behind two young women, separated by a century, are united in their determination to fight for the thing they love most - whatever the cost.

My thoughts:

Jojo Moyes’ The Girl You Left Behind is a dual time novel spanning almost 100 years, partly set in France during WW1 and partly in 21st century London. 

France, 1916: with their husbands fighting away at the front, Sophie LeFèvre and her sister Hélène are running their family’s bar and restaurant, Le Coq Rouche, despite dwindling supplies and the ever increasing oppression of their German occupiers. When the German army requisitions their hotel to have the soldiers’ meals prepared there, it puts the two women in a difficult position – on one hand they are unable to deny their occupiers, on the other they can ill afford to be seen as collaborators and traitors in their own village for feeding and housing the enemy. Things go from bad to worse when a German kommandant spots a portrait Sophie’s husband Eduard painted of his wife when they first fell in love. Initially drawn by the brushwork, the attraction soon threatens to become more personal, putting Sophie in a very dangerous situation.


London, 2006: Olivia “Liv” Halston, still struggling to come to terms with her husband David’s sudden death four years ago, has no knowledge of the history of the painting, “The Girl You Left Behind”, which David purchased for her on their honeymoon in Spain almost a decade earlier. Over the years, the painting has become a source of great solace for her, and she has formed a kind of bond with the woman the picture portrays. When Liv allows herself to fall in love with a man she met in a bar one night, she has little idea of the far reaching effects the encounter will have on her whole life. Through a bizarre coincidence she is suddenly caught up in a bitter battle over the true ownership of the painting, not only threatening her memory of happy times with her husband, but also her new relationship.


Moyes throws up some interesting premises with her novel – the power of art to capture and convey events in history for generations to come, and the true meaning of ownership. In one scene Liv, who sees herself as the rightful owner and guardian of the painting, points out a controversial issue: if all items which have been the spoils of war were to be re-possessed, then most famous historical artworks would be the centre of bitter court battles. Indeed, where would we stop – by relinquishing whole towns, cities, countries which have been occupied and taken from their previous owners? How can it be fairly determined what really constitutes rightful ownership? It did make me think, and I could relate to Liv’s plight. Although I must admit that I would have liked Liv to have a deeper connection to the painting rather than a random purchase – as it was, I could not fully comprehend her willingness to sacrifice everything for the painting, her house, her new love, her reputation.


As far as reading pleasure goes, I was totally captivated by the narrative of Sophie’s story. Having listened to the audiobook version of the novel, I take my hat off to the two narrators who did an outstanding job of bringing the characters to life. Especially Sophie’s life story was told with such feeling that I often had tears in my eyes as her fate unfolded. On that subject, I must admit that I enjoyed the historical parts of the story much more than the contemporary chapters, which at times dragged just a little – or maybe I was just so eager to find out more about Sophie’s fate that I had little patience for Liv’s emotional crises One big gripe I had with Liv’s story was that Moyes heavily relies on coincidence to unfold the main plotline, which makes parts of the story a bit far fetched. However, as my kids always remind me when I am too picky, this is fiction after all, and that aside I certainly enjoyed the ride. The Girl You Left Behind cements Moyes as an author I want to read more of in the future.

I read this book as part of my 2013 Audiobook Challenge

.

Book Review: THE RAILWAYMAN'S WIFE by Ashley Hay

Title: The Railwayman's Wife
Author: Ashley Hay
Publisher: Allen & Unwin
Read: March 16 - 23, 2013



Synopsis (Goodreads):

In a small town on the land's edge, in the strange space at a war's end, a widow, a poet and a doctor each try to find their own peace, and their own new story.

In Thirroul, in 1948, people chase their dreams through the books in the railway's library. Anikka Lachlan searches for solace after her life is destroyed by a single random act. Roy McKinnon, who found poetry in the mess of war, has lost his words and his hope. Frank McKinnon is trapped by the guilt of those his treatment and care failed on their first day of freedom. All three struggle with the same question: how now to be alive.

Written in clear, shining prose and with an eloquent understanding of the human heart, The Railwayman's Wife explores the power of beginnings and endings, and how hard it can be sometimes to tell them apart. It's a story of life, loss and what comes after; of connection and separation, longing and acceptance. Most of all, it celebrates love in all its forms, and the beauty of discovering that loving someone can be as extraordinary as being loved yourself.

A story that will break your heart with hope.


My thoughts:

In Thirroul in 1948 the sound of the railway is a steady presence in Annika Lachlan’s life. Then one day the trains don’t run – there has been an accident further up the line, Annika is told, and her husband Mac’s life has been lost. Suddenly widowed and alone with her eleven year old daughter Bella, Ani is forced to take a job as librarian in the small town’s library.

Enveloped in her grief but forced out of solitude by her new job, Ani comes into contact with other hurt souls. Roy McKinnon, a poet, whose wartime experiences have left him unable to write about the beauty he sees all around him. Doctor Frank Draper, recently returned from Germany where he has witnessed unspeakable horrors after the liberation of the concentration camps, and who blames himself for being unable to prevent the deaths of many patients in his care. And Iris McKinnon, who has waited years for her sweetheart to return from the war, only to find him scarred and battered, a changed man.

As these troubled people meet, they find solace in each other’s company as they try to rebuild their lives and come to term with their individual grief.

Hay’s beautiful prose takes the reader on a heartbreaking journey of discovery of loss and grief and the way different people deal with tragedy. As Annika progresses through the different stages of sudden widowhood – the shock, the anger, the fear and the bottomless sorrow – her job in the town’s library brings her into contact with other people scarred by tragedy. Slowly she manages to bring joy back into her life, but her husband’s death remains an omnipresent void in her life.

“The year I’ve had, Dr Draper, here, with my daughter, making sense of this strange new world. I’ve lost my husband. I have this job. I wake up in my room, in my house. And yet everything, everything is different.”

It took me quite a long time to connect with the characters in this book, but once I did I was quickly drawn into the story and its emotional landscape. The blurb talks about hope, and yet hope was a fleeting thing for me, like sunshine only briefly breaking through the clouds. It left me wondering if the people in the story could ever be whole again, especially after closing the last page. At what stage is the damage too great to ever being able to move on, to start anew?

Anyone who has ever lost a loved one will be able to relate to some of the emotions described in this story. The Railwayman’s Wife is not a cheerful book but one which invites introspection and reflection. It also skilfully draws the reader’s attention to the emotional legacy of war, and its repercussions long after it is over, and many continents away from the battlefields. With her poetic prose, Hay brings to life the atmosphere of a small coastal town in post-war Australia and its people. 

Thank you to the publisher Allen & Unwin for supplying me with a free copy of this novel. The thoughts expressed in this review are strictly my own.

This book forms part of my 2013 Australian Women Writers Challenge.